The discourse surrounding the regulation of a prospective market for tokenized equities in the U.S. is intensifying, as traditional finance (TradFi) institutions on Wall Street clash with cryptocurrency leaders. This conflict centers on whether decentralized trading platforms should be regulated similarly to traditional exchanges, as highlighted in a recent report by HSBC.
Tokenization refers to the transformation of real-world asset ownership—spanning stocks, bonds, real estate, private equity, and even art—into digital tokens that are logged on a blockchain.
The report emphasized a recent meeting of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Investor Advisory Committee, where opinions diverged on the oversight of on-chain equity trading.
Citadel Securities, a leading TradFi firm, has faced backlash from the crypto community for advocating a more stringent approach to decentralized finance (DeFi). Scott Bauguess, Coinbase’s vice president for global regulatory policy, has called for regulations specifically tailored for decentralized exchange models.
On the regulatory front, SEC Chair Paul Atkins reiterated the importance of creating compliant frameworks that also foster innovation, while Commissioner Caroline Crenshaw raised alarms about the potential risks associated with tokenized equities.
A key element in this discussion is a 13-page letter from Citadel to the SEC, asserting that numerous DeFi trading protocols fit the definition of an exchange and should be regulated as such, according to analysts Daragh Maher and Nishu Singla.
Citadel cautioned that broad exemptions for DeFi could lead to regulatory arbitrage and establish a “shadow market” that provides less protection for investors compared to traditional platforms.
Where the SEC will eventually set the regulatory boundaries remains uncertain, the analysts noted.
While Atkins envisions tokenization as a means to modernize U.S. capital markets, it’s improbable that the agency will allow a U.S.-facing, on-chain equities market to function with significantly fewer protections than traditional exchanges, the analysts suggested.
A likely regulatory approach involves the creation of a “sandbox,” permitting tokenized equity platforms to operate under specific conditions as regulators explore applicable boundaries, particularly regarding U.S.-facing transactions and identifiable teams, according to the bank.
Over time, HSBC predicted that regulatory pressures could shift favorably towards tokenized equities trading on entirely permissioned and regulated blockchains.
Nevertheless, the report concluded that there is one consensus among TradFi, DeFi, and regulators: The tokenization sector is expected to expand from a modest foundation, and the intensity of the ongoing debate signals that the stakes are escalating rapidly.
Read more: Bernstein Says U.S. Crypto Framework Positions Nation as Global Leader
