As EU lawmakers approach a conclusion on the contentious “Chat Control” legislation, privacy experts caution that it could undermine public trust in online communications and drive users toward Web3 platforms.
As European lawmakers draw closer to a verdict on the debated “Chat Control” bill, privacy specialists alert that it might erode public confidence in digital communication and lead users to Web3 alternatives.
Central to the discussion is the EU’s proposed Regulation to Prevent and Combat Child Sexual Abuse, mandating platforms to scan private messages for unlawful content prior to encryption. Detractors argue this essentially establishes a backdoor in encrypted systems, violating the EU’s own privacy commitments.
“Providing a potentially corruptible entity with extensive visibility into individuals’ private lives contradicts the foundational principles of digital privacy,” Hans Rempel, co-founder and CEO of Diode, stated. He described the proposal as an alarming overextension.
Elisenda Fabrega, general counsel at Brickken, emphasized that the law seems “hard to justify under current jurisprudence of the Court of Justice of the European Union.” She highlighted Articles 7 and 8 of the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights, which ensure the confidentiality of communications and safeguard personal data.
“Client-side scanning would allow for the monitoring of content on user devices before transmission, even in instances without any indication of unlawful behavior,” she clarified.
Related: US Treasury’s DeFi ID initiative is ‘like installing cameras in every home’
EU law sets troubling precedent
Experts contend that the regulation sets a troubling precedent both legally and technologically. “There are no assurances,” Rempel added, regarding the potential misuse of tools. “Over 10% of all data breaches occur within government systems,” he cautioned.
Fabrega expressed concerns about the wider implications of such surveillance on public trust. “Encryption is not merely a technical feature; it’s a commitment to users that their private communications will remain confidential,” she stated.
The diminishing trust in conventional messaging platforms might encourage users to seek decentralized Web3 options, which are designed to safeguard user data through inherent encryption.
“Web3’s privacy battle cry is ‘Not your keys, not your data,’” Rempel remarked. “This represents true self-custody for data,” he added, mentioning that users retain control over their information from “cradle to grave.”
Fabrega supported this view, indicating that “privacy-focused users will increasingly consider decentralized Web3 alternatives” if the Chat Control measure passes. She warned that this transition could “fragment the European digital market” and weaken the EU’s capacity to influence global privacy norms.
Related: EU initiative to scan all private messages gains traction
The ball is in Germany’s court
Germany, which holds the crucial vote, has not yet taken a definitive position. While 15 EU nations currently back the proposal, they do not meet the 65% population threshold necessary for enactment. If Germany supports it, the law will likely succeed; if it abstains or opposes, the legislation is expected to falter.
“We consider the chances of passage to be low,” Rempel commented. “However, this won’t be the last attempt to compromise fundamental human rights in the name of safety.”
Magazine: Astrology could enhance your prowess as a crypto trader: The signs predict it
